« February 2005 | Main | April 2005 »

March 31, 2005

New Release for the Pocket PC 1.1.0.4

As an owner of a Dell Axium X30 this makes me a happy camper. Packed with 6 new featues all which were on my wish list...

Here is the changelog:
feature: ability to leave Skype Voicemail
feature: SkypeIn support
feature: centralized Contacts list
feature: support for high-resolution display
feature: SkypeOut fixes (calling to France numbers)
feature: exit and close Skype application from Tools menu
change: additional languages (German, French)
change: improved communication security
bugfix: error message when calling from search result
bugfix: blocked contact offline icon incorrect
bugfix: incorrect message in case of password change
bugfix: Skype was unusable on Chinese PPC

SkypeTiVo - Personal

CNet is reporting on SkypeCasting and iPodradio. So I thought I'd announce now the experiment I'll be looking to try with Skype Video when it finally arrives.

The "implications are very disruptive," according to the SkypeJournal, a well-known Web community that provides Skypecast instructions. "Many Skypers want to record their Skype conversations and turn them into podcasts."
CNET News.com

SkypeTiVo is created by pointing Skype (with video) not at the webcam but at an installed TV card in your desktop PC. This assumes you will be able to choose your video device just like an audio-in channel. So now when Skype auto-answers you can watch your own TV from PC anywhere. With a little API plug-in and some dtmf tones you could probably change the channel on the remote TV. It's probably not quite that easy.

Possible? I don't know. However Orb Networks and others are trialing this currently. No reason why Skype couldn't be adapted.

Handset or Headset or What?

Are you selling a range of telecom products? Are you studying Skype? What are you doing to make your products more Skype friendly? "Handset, Headset or What?" is not meant to provide the the answers or the outline for a research plan. It starts with some basics. Just observe yourself when trying out different devices. When it comes to research more care is required. While solutions for "connecting" Skype predominate today, I believe the opportunities may really exist in deeper study of the form factors and observing how we really use Skype.

I first posted about Phones and Skype in October 2003. At CES there was more progress and over the last few weeks I've found myself testing handheld phone solutions again. I'll report on the actual phones separately, however I've made some observations about my own behavior depending on the type of device I'm using. Currently there are three real options for Skypers connected to a PC. 1) A headset (typically stereo) either corded or wireless (bluetooth), 2) some phone handsets again in cordless and wireless renditions, or resorting to 3)speakers and mic.

The Handset (traditional phone):

With handsets one naturally holds the handset to their ear. Looking in on my usage I tend to sit back away from my computer, I use less texting, and the device doesn't encourage typing extra links. This is certainly true for the corded variety. With a cordless I can more freely walk about. Thus very appropriate for taking calls from another room or letting someone else in the house dial the world on SkypeOut (some phones only) without interferring with the PC etc. When phone handset are well integrated using the SkypeAPI the keypad becomes integrated and with SkypeIn and Out be substitued for a traditional phone, even when you have switched users on your PC.

The Headset (traditional computer):
With the headset my hands remain free, I've nothing to hold to my ear, typing and working sometimes even on other pieces concurrently --- multi-tasking is easier. However how I sit and engage with Skype is now tied to the PC. I tend to sit much more forward. It's easier to keep focused on work mode. However the corded headset tends to be messy. There is no phone rest to put it down, the cord is too long or too short and putting it on quickly well it just isn't as easy as picking up a receiver. Plus I'm used to calling others and hearing them scramble for headsets. Thus the standard headset is rather clunky. Many of the corded objections go away when a bluetooth headset is put on. It's light weight and improves mobility versus holding a typcial cordless handset. Although listening through one ear is not quite the same, (I'm yet to find the perfect stereo solution.) and connecting BT headsets can be a problem.

Just Speakers and Mic
Note many are just using desktop speakers and a well placed mic (usually very low cost) for their Skype calls. I had one journalist tell me that was the easiest way to record the call. My father uses it and I've used my laptop that way too. (For the most part laptops are better when you plug in mini earphones (the mic is often too close to the speakers and the caller gets feedback). Plus there is the example of video where many webcams have their own mic input. So some toggling between devices and outputs is becoming increasingly necessary. It's worth considering this approach too. In fact many introduce a toggle switch to go between headset and speaker, just because their PC and room then becomes like a giant speakerphone system. There are also speakerphone options that when there are groups at each end of the line can make calls more interesting.

The contrast appears very obvious. So why am I writing about it? There is an opportunity within the enterprise to rethink the communication devices used (don't just replace the handset) and separately for the consumer there are different situaltional trade-offs. You may want to have a phone, speakers, mic, bluetooth, etc. Simply all of the devices. Depending on the where and when and with who.. you may simply take the calls in different ways. The solutions could be bundled or they may be separate. However the Skyper that adopts a PDA or a small mobile solution now with WiFi in the house and office may begin to adopt very different calling behaviors. Particularly where "presence" is involved.

Without thinking many organizations are buying VoIP hardware ready desktop phones. Are enough CEO's asking why put big new VoIP phones on employee desktops when the employee spends more time mobile, in meetings, working at home etc. Is it just a complete waste of money? Could the job be done better by software and other options? The enterprise units don't add to mobility, encourage "arm lock-up" and aren't making it easier to integrate activities with IM or other desktop sharing. By contrast the solutions that integrate with the desktop and encourage multiple communications forms, make it easier to share presence etc have a much better opportunity for success. Could my mobile work seemlessly as my Skype dialer and even take calls over bluetooth when in the right proximity to my desktop or laptop? Similarly inserting a bluetooth headset adds another other dimension. If the right "software" was available would this be attractive?

I'm sure a market for phones remains. I'm just less certain about the implcations of what device to recommend. There's been lots of "press recently" about the Actiontec USB device. I mentioned in this post my missgivings (see also these Skype Forum threads) that it wasn't really integrated through the SkypeAPI. So what do you buy? If you also have SkypeIn and SkypeOut then adding a cordless phone makes a lot of sense. Adding one that integrates with Skype becomes even more interesting. Although the cordless versions like Siemens and the Olympia DualPhone are expensive. Thus the appeal remains for the USB devices. With one you can use your old phone, take Skype calls and perhaps set up some speed dial numbers. However for the most part you will still have to "click" your screen to choose a lessor known or non preprogrammed buddy. You may or maynot be able to direct dial SkypeOut calls. You can solve that all with a CyberphoneK

Like headsets there are also some devices that use the audio output and input jacks to connect phones or phone like handsets. Chat-Cord and Let's-Chat are examples of this type of product. They are some of the lowest cost solutions available.

This could easily lead to plenty of consumer confusion. When Skype goes video, some will add webcams for the first time. What's the best solution for that? Are webcams going to slip into the enterprise.. not very likely shorterm.

As telephony merges with software the determining factors will be what form factor you want to use to make the audio connection. Speakerphone, mobile handset, headset etc. They could be yesterdays world in an instant with voice dialing. Then dialing also becomes more and more irrelevant with "presence" and buddylists. Simply click or "voice" activate to connect. We are on the cusp of a new revolution in form factors and design for conversing. It can be made simpler. I'm still waiting for the iPod for telephony. Consumers want products they are comfortable with. Unfortunately even the newest Skypers won't tell you what you should design next. They are still becoming aquainted with the product. I'd like to see more product designs emerging that are thinking well forward and concurrently pressing Skype to more innovation. I wonder... Will the next iPod be Skype friendly?

Skype Talking

I have a friend from Australia that swims in 50 meter pools around the world. Via Skype I met Graham who wants to Skype every country in the world. I'm sure he is not alone and many blogs profess this same desire to connect with new people.

I will share my Skypeing others and when I am Skyped by others. My goal is to establish connections in every country that Skype is available and then some.

I talk to people in English speaking countries more than others and it probably has something to do with my lack of ability to speak other languages. Skype Talking

Skype him. This is his button.

Freedom to Connect

Jeff Jarvis, and some great people are participating in David Isenberg's "Freedom to Connect" meeting. I'd hoped to go. At least I know the Skype message is sinking in.

.... thanks to a six programmers somewhere in Europe (read: Skype) had eliminated the need for phone companies ... and paying them $1 trillion dollars. So what will we do with that trillion, we people? Feed people? Solve the energy problem? What? Jeff Jarvis

A live audio feed is available.

March 30, 2005

Outlook Skype

Peter Kalmstrom has been developing plug-ins for Microsoft Outlook for a long time. Now he too has created a solution to integrate Skype into your contact list.

OSCallSkypeOut1.jpg

The next big thing in the IT world is telephony and voice. There will be a lot of interesting developments in this area in the years to come. One of those developments is already here: Skype. It is a peer-to-peer network based IP Telephony application. I like it a lot and decided to build an Outlook add-in for it. Outlook Skype

Skype and Treo Solution

Steve writes in Adventures in Home Networking how he coordinates his Treo and SkypeIn and SkypeOut into one effective communications solution. He doesn't like to mess around with headphones. He documents his solution for the home office, around the house, and around town. He sums it up as completely changing the way he communicates.

At my home office:

* when I get home I put my mobile (Treo 600) in its cradle and this initiates an automatic auto-forward to my SkypeIn number, which also comes with free voicemail.Microphone
* at my desk I am using my Logitech noise cancelling USB Microphone and my desktops speakers, people tell me the quality is very good – so there is no need to mess around with headphones
Adventures in home working

iChat-iPod

Om notes that the iPod phone is held up. I'm inclined to believe there is another opportunity.

Who really prevented the iTunes phone from being released? Motorola blamed the finicky Steve Jobs and his marketing approach for the delay. Business Week says it was the carriers who might be behind the delay. “Behind the clash are two very different views of the future of music on mobile phones. Om Malik

Consider combining iChat for Tiger with the iPod, currently looking like a Skype on steriods. Then launch the capability along with a next generation iPod that makes it backward compatible. The installed base makes it interesting. The demographics make it neat and who's going to upgrade their cell when Wi-Fi an iPod and an iChat dongle and software upgrade via iTunes will make those call for free? Perfect for the campus.

The iPod photo can even do color iChat video with an upgrade. the iPod dial is perfect too. Too far fetched?

While Skype is generating a millions of new users and being chased by PC knock-offs, their professed strategy is to go mobile. Outside the mobile phone market at the moment the hotest device is not the PDA, it's an iPod. The right price and millions could be calling.

Which company can hack it first. iSkypePod or iChatPod? iTunes provides a platform that with todays music lists.. could also extend into the social arena. Let's face it most iPod users have PC's. iChat on an iPod provides a good reason to have iChat on a PC too. How long will it take?

Skype buzz triples in six months

In October 2004, when the blogosphere was all about the U.S. Presidential campaign, Skype was mentioned in .015 to .020 percent of blogs. That level of attention remained the same through year end. Then something changed and word started to spread. Six months' later, Skype buzz is solidly in the 0.045% range. via BlogPulse.

Just for context, "Bush" was discussed on 22% of all blogs when he was reelected (1000 times more popular a topic) and "steroids" spiked twice to 0.25 (10 times more popular). Big movement. Early days.

March 29, 2005

Toggle Audio on the Mac

Can a Mac user confirm this works and the quality of the program?


Toggle Sound Output 0.2b
Freeware | 3.28.05 | Script #2123
Author: Johan van Oostrum | Developer's Web Site
Release Notes:

This script toggles between two sound outputs. e.g. the standard speakers and a headset.

It is a simple script that comes handy if you use a headset for a VOIP service like Skype. For use with languages other than Dutch or English you have to slightly modify the script.
Macscripter

Robin Good on Video

Robin Good reflects on the new wave of audio video technologies. Be sure to check out Microsoft Portrait.

That we are about to see an increasing number of Skype-like technologies enter the market, each one providing easy over IP audio and video capabilities while integrating more advanced functions and controls it is only a matter of time. Robin Good

SkypeTV

There's a great post on PlasticBag about social software for settop boxes. Where are the points where television and PVR use meetup with Skyping?

  • Share my Skype buddy lists. The Skype network is both huge and international. Save me from duplicating effort yet again; let me use my Skype contacts in my TV's buddy list.
  • Use the Skype network for presence. Skypespace can inform my TV's settop box of who's connected, in what mode, and where. This should allow me to watch socially even if I'm on a different cable network.
  • Trigger live conversations. Let my TV show me that five of my buddies are watching the semifinals live. Then give us the option to chat or conference call.
  • Share media. Snapshots, audio clips, and video clips from the show with my buddies. Make it easy, no more than 2-3 clicks.

What else?

What's your Skype strategy?

Pardon me, sir, but what's your Skype strategy? Don't you have one? I mean you're the CIO around here, and you have an email strategy, a web strategy. Hell, you even have a blog strategy (so 2004). So what's your Skype strategy? Someone on your team must be able to write up some 30/90/180 day goals. By next week.

Why bother? It's a disruptive technology, bub. You don't want to be caught with your pants around your ankles. Again.

So come up with a story, short and sweet, light on tech jargon. Say how we're going to embrace/defend/coopt the "New Microsoft of Voice," the next Ma Bell. How you're gonna use free/cheap voice over the Internet to get us closer to customers, to listen (yeah, right), to cut the cost of customer service and ... support. Kill off a legacy problem. You'll list existing systems we'll hook up to Skype to create competitive advantage.

Brainstorm 25 things you can do.

Pick six.

Do three.

You'll have something to brag about.

Pick Skype point people. A developer to read the Skype programming docs, so you know what's doable, and a manager to carry the torch.

Your Skype Strategy paints Skype with every management buzzword hard, soft, and personal.

Lead with cold logic, old friend. Cheap local numbers everywhere. Your telephone hardware budget and that VoIP project you've been putting off vs. free software. Skype's 92 million downloads and 7 billion minutes served in just two years, as the biggest and fastest pool of communicators since IM and the mobile phone.

Then warm them up with productivity:

  • knowledge management through information sharing,
  • collaboration with well timed conversations,
  • team cohesion of offshored projects using Skype presence,
  • Skype logs as a fodder for the learning organization.

Close with the small stuff: convenience, portability, configurability, fun.

philwolffgraydottedthumbnai.jpgBrag about your Skype strategy to your friends. Download Skype for your kids (if they'll let you). Brag to your suppliers. To your competitors' CIOs. To your major accounts. To your head of marketing. To your staffing director. Pass out business cards with your Skype Name on it.

And close conversations by asking, "so, what's your Skype strategy?"

Skype me when you're ready to brainstorm, prioritize, or brag.

March 28, 2005

New law highlights a huge Video market....

A lot of Skypers want video. Many though wonder why video is important. For 34 million kids in America who have a parent living in a different city video conferencing can be a miracle. Lawmakers in Utah passed the first Virtual Visitation Law in the United States. And it looks like Wisconsin will be next.

Skyper Michael Gough "mgough" is president for a group pushing for video visitation rights.

This sounds like a excellent real-world application for Skype and other VoIP systems. Currently Michael uses SightSpeed for video and Skype for audio.

Michael shared with me three critical functions necessary for vendors to be successful in this market sector-

1. Security. Parents must be able to limit what access their child has to other users. For Skype this means a child should not be able to access the privacy options. Currently they can. Can we get parental control for this option? This is of paramount importance in a court is going to approve video visitation privledges.

2. Freedom to place the video pics any where on the monitor the user wants and at any size they want. This functionality is easily understood when you watch the different activities a parent and child share during a visitation. Sharing a book, showing off a missing tooth, waving, throwing a kiss... all require flexibility of positioning and sizing the pics; and trading off resolution and framerate.

The image size is also important for grandparents. For the vision impaired resolution is not the key issue. Big counts.

3. Support for the hearing impaired: Grandma is an important player in this blended-family market. Voice to text captioning is needed.

We will have more to say as this story unfolds over the coming weeks. An aging population and the growing multi-parent dispersed family are the drivers for Video Conferencing. Developers who understand demographics may have more power than those who understand technology.

March 27, 2005

Does Skype offer "best-in-class" Security?

Is Skype security really a "concern"? Or is it already best in class? I was pointed by Neville Hobson to the newest release of "VoIP and Skype Security" (by Simson L. Garfinkel) relased by The Tactical Technology Collective, an Amsterdam-based non-governmental organization.

The speculation may be a mute point. While the article details potential risks a balanced reader would draw the conclusion that Skype relative to other VoIP products, ISDN and the phone system is already very secure. At the end of the article the author suggests eight strategies. If you follow 1 through 6 and appropriate CIA codes and never operate for more than 3 minutes or behind a firewall then you will probably be as secure as anyone on earth that uses a phone. Put a 100 million users on Skype and it will be hard to find you. Add your own audio encryption on the PC ends and you are probably safe. New names for everycall etc.

Overly dramatised? Perhaps! The point is this article raises important security questions. However, for the most part you should direct them at both Skype and everyone else in the VoIP, ISDN and telecom market. The new article is much improved, with clear input from Skype staff. The question I would pose is:

What products outside of VPN offer better security? If so, what is the cost of adding that level of security and for whose benefit is it? What risk on security are we really running. Disenfranchised employees may well be a larger security risk. Two key types of security risks are identified. 1) boundary; access through the firewall, and 2)system failure - do you have a backup plan.

There are some points of fact that require further revision.

1. On Page 3 Simson states that "voice quality was significantly degraded" when connected via a dialup modem at 26 kbps. The minimun specification stated by Skype is 32 kbps so why is this point in the document?

2. On page 6, Simson says, "It is not known if a supernode can monitor the voice traffic moving through it." It has not yet been shown that in fact voice traffic is ever carried by or through a supernode. This thread on the Skype Forum with comments from Skype Staffer jaan seems to indicate it does not. In fact Skype has said that the maximum bandwidth used on a Supernode is 5kbs. Since a call requires a minimum of 32kps you can be sure that the supernode never has access to your encrypted voice stream.

3. On Page 8, another error of fact. "...when Skype is used over an 802.11 wireless network. In this case, voice quality suffers considerably." I suggest some 20 percent of Skype Users in fact use Skype on such a network. I know of no degredation.

For more information on Skype security I recommend this thread on on the Skype Forum. Of particular note is Jaan's comment that sums up all of Simson's concerns in one line instead of 9 pages, "security: well, it should be obvious that one should not use Skype security layer to run a bank."

We'd suggest that there are some "security" tweaks you could pursue today to protect your organization from some of the risks listed in Simson's article and get going with Skype. We understand the enterprise has specific security needs. We believe many of these can be handed with an appropriate SkypeAPI enabled plug-in. That would be a great first step in "building a test case" and developing an effective "enterprise" Skype strategy.

Video Directions: Apple's iChat sets the pace...

iChatTiger.jpg Anyone who is interested in video conferencing with Skype will want to view this demo of Apple's iChat it is truly an wow moment.

I can't wait to test iChat to measure the bandwidth consumed. I would suggest this sets a high bar for Skype as a entrant to video conferencing. This is clearly both cool and "best-in-class".

SkypeIn Plan for Rollover Numbers

Is Skype about to turn the Call Center Industry on it's head? Is a Skype rollover numbers strategy (that cut's out the Telcos) about to emerge? It could with a few learnings from the testing team behind the Skype Journal. Is SkypeIn on the verge of radically shaking the corporate enterprise market for one of it's largest telecom cost centers. If you run a call center, or even have multiple lines into your business the opportunity demonstrated below may shock you. Consider the following scenario:

An entrepreneur is growing rapidly, his call center is outsourced and he needs to bring it in house for better quality. He's going to set up a bank of PC's to handle it. He goes to Walmart and purchases 50 Xandros Linux ready Skype PC's at $200 and adds another $300 for quality screen and a couple of other miscellaneous bits. He loads them all up with Skype and logs everyone of them on to "CorporateCallCenter". He goes to the Skype account page and purchases one SkypeIn Account for one year at a cost of 30 Euros and buys E50 worth of minutes. He's ready to go. His staff can now handle up to 50 concurrent calls in bound or outbound all using the same line and account.
In a few months it may be that simple or even simpler if you use a home based call center strategy. This post is split up into four parts. 1)Background what you need to know, 2)The initial tests we made and conclusions, 3)Strategy implications and 4)What to test.

1 Background: What you need to know.
A. Extensions: You can run Skype under the same profile name on multiple computers concurrently. Inbound calls ring all clients whether in a call or not. Thus you can share the same line on multiple PC's even concurrently talking to different individuals. Example three PC's running in the office all with the same account name. One is actively engaged in a call.
B. SkypeOut: You can now dial multiple Skypeout numbers from the same PC, thus create a SkypeOut conference call with up to four people (I've not tried more). If you have an "extension" PC running as above you or another person can call a completely different group of people even while that first PC is engaged. Alternatively the second PC is available for a SkypeIn Call.
C. SkypeIn. SkypeIn is Skype's new service that allows you to secure "landline" PSTN style numbers for your Skype Account. This is currently limted to three per account. Thus if you purchase one SkypeIn number your PC will ring. Just like in A above if you are running the same client on more than one PC you can receive more than one SkypeIn call. Take the first call on the first PC from 14151234567 and then on the second PC (same SkypeIn number) take the second call from 1415 7654321.
D. Voice Mail: Voice mail picks up when there is no client available to take the call or the inbound call is sent / diverted to voice mail.


The tests and conclusions.
1. Running "my_name" on two PC's I dialed my 415 SkypeIn number first with my Vonage account. I answered on the first PC. Left it connected. Took my home phone, dialed my 415 SkypeIn number again. Answered that with the second PC. Left it connected. Thus at this point I had two different conversations going. I then tried dialing with my cellphone and I naturally got voice mail for the two instances were tied up in different calls. Voice mail was deliverd to both open clients.

2. I made the first SkypeOut call to a UK SkypeIn number which rang both his active PC's. I left that call connected I went to my second PC, and using SkypeOut dialed exactly the same UK SkypeIn number. Now there were to completely separate but in otherways Identical calls. Both were completely separate and private from each other. We then duplicated test one above. Note the billing implications of this. One SkypeOut account could provide lines out for many people.

3. I then made a SkypeOut call to Bill's UK SkypeIn number and then using Vonage dialed Bill's US SkypeIn number. For some reason it rang but didn't connect, sending me to voice mail. (Note will Bill's US number it failed, with his UK number it worked, with mine it worked etc. However not 100%)

4. Note when in one call and the second PC takes a call the ringing stops. If you were doing this is more than two PCs (eg the 50 example) you would want to turn off the ringers and create another "notification" approach for inbound calls. Eg the flashing red light. Call centers are managed by minutes and numbers served so there's an incentive to be the first to pick it up. Like playing Snap.

5. In the Skype config XML file (in the hidden applications folder) there is a line that allows multiple inbound calls. Thus this suggests that this is either a feature or something that Skype may try to control or enable control over in the future. There are some elements that also need additional work. For example where an account is associated with more than one SkypeIn line. How do you know which one is being called. The account may provide the context.

Skype Strategy:

We would suggest Skype maintain the "as many "calls" concurrently as you have multiple clients open and cap it between 3 and 5. Skype architecture is clear the "extensions" concept is embedded in the design.

We believe that Skype could offer a 1-800 number and then offer the equivalent of mulitple lines by simply applying a setting in the accounts system. Thus you could buy a 50 line-in package. This would eliminate traditional rollover. Skype could do this "dirt" cheap. Say $5 per year for each extra extension.

The big element missing from the above is the capability to associate more than one account name with the open Skype client. For example In the call center we want to load up the buddy list with the 50 operators names taking calls. From the one client any of the operators should be able to text or conference in one of the other operators. This needs to be possible without running a second client (although easy to do) on everyone's PC. Perhaps the solution will come in "internal" call forwarding.

Skype call forwarding will be very important. While many of us want it already to forward our SkypeIn line to our mobile phone, the capability to hand off a call to someone else logged into the same client requires each client to be able to poll for others like it and then redirect to the correct extension. This thought could be extended and is very important to the enterprise or small business. What we are talking about is probably a modified "supernode".

The Skype API provides many opportunities in this area from statistics to call management and notification. Similarly it can be used to drive page support dependent on number called or customer details etc. All in all don't underestimate the power of what's feasible now above.

Call Center Implications:
Hardware?: Skype could radically reduce cost and complexity at the backend. Is only one number really necessary? What happened to "mulitple" lines required? Should you think about it as a "call center"?
Organization and Structure: What does a decentralised P2P call center look like. Rather than the scenario above what happens when you Skype enable a distributed call center. Each worker has their own PC, a broadband connection Skype and an API plug-in that provides reporting and random recording for quality control. The cost of this equipment setup is zero.

Time to Test!
Test multi-PC's. We are particularly interested to hear from those that are willing to test 10 or more PC's in a concept test. We will help you set it up running two SKype clients concurrently on each machine.
We don't have confirmation from Skype that what we've learned we can do today is either a feature (they weren't planning to make noise about yet) or a bug. We certainly hope that it is not the latter.
We would be happy to discuss further with call center operators.

In conclusion we believe there are some simple strategies emerging for powering up a small enterprise using Skype and a well crafted SkypeAPI plugin manager that can direct calls and enable appropriate support.

March 25, 2005

HotRecorder - Record Skype Calls

Hotrecorder.pngThe hot product of the week award goes to HotRecorder. With the capability to not only answer Skype Calls but record them as well. This is the first "free product" to enable one click SkypeCasting. I tested it today as both an answerphone and Skype Call recorder. It worked very effectively in both modes. It also enables you to insert "emotisounds" into any conversation whether you are recording or not.

A shortened description:

HotRecorder™ allows users to record and add sound effects (Emotisounds™) on voice communications held over the internet. It also includes voice mail for Skype™!

The creation of HotRecorder™ responds to the growing demand of users throughout the world, for a tool that will allow them to record, play, save, send and search their voice communications, plus many other options. HotRecorder

Observations:

  • Free Version: I used the free version and immediately hated the "advertising". If you want to record or use it frequently you will happily pay the $14.95.

  • The interface is very clean and professional. It's easy to work through the various functions.
  • It was very easy to setup an e-mail forwarding function. So when a Skype call is received it is saved and then automatically forwarded to an e-mail address of my choice. (see note below)
  • After recording my first Skype Call it was easy to name the file and save details of the call. It then allowed me to send it to my test partner. I entered their e-mail and it was sent immediately by Outlook (not yet working with Outlook Express) along with a message to get HotRecorder.
  • Note: You can only play the recorded files on a HotRecorder. This is a very slick viral strategy. It also immediately frustrated me. For while I can e-mail voice messages received... sending them to my phone won't work. It's not a format I can play there. Similarly I'm not sure how I'd edit them into a podcast.

    Using it with Skype:
    Now it's very cool that HotRecorder has captured windows audio so effectively. I can't yet vouch for what it does if you are in one call and get another while you are recording one as a podcast. You can disable the voice mail recorder however I think you will get the "ringing" of the inbound line in your podcast. The only way to fix that currently would be to put a silent ringer in your wave file.

    HotRecorder doesn't dock with the SkypeAPI in anyway. Consequently any calls it answers for Skype are just listed as "Conversation with VoiceMail" with the date and time. This contrasts with the efforts of SAM and Pamela which captures who left a message and make it a simple one click to answer back.

    Similarly HotRecorder provides no warning to other Skypers that they are now being recorded. If HotRecorder was integrated with the SkypeAPI then whenever the "recording" button was hit it could send a text message to the other caller. Similarly it could text that recording was stopped or paused. I really hope they come and ask us some questions. It would be a shame not to integrate it in this way. It's an obvious upgrade and would provide some significant new product features and benefits.

    I've not looked too closely at the "recording" file format. The desire to have the capability to manipulate the file for podcasts means this format needs a converter. Who can provide it by Monday? Then again, If podcasters are comfortable recording and distributing in this format there will soon be a lot of HotRecorders out there.

    Similarly there are some different quality setting. Which I've not experimented with yet. HotRecorder won't enable you to record iTunes and the Skype Call at the same time.

    See also ZDNet

  • Voice Mail Storage - Skype's Solution

    I was asked this morning how Skype stores voice mail on their server. A few tests uncover the secret sauce that creates a more efficient and lower cost VM system. Plus, did you know that Skype Voice Mail can follow you from PC to PC although not always?

    Let's start with the Skype client. With the latest version "contacts" follow you. So you can easily log on anywhere, leave a PC on at home, open your laptop, be in an internet café. When you are logged in on multiple PC's with the same ID at the same time an inbound call will make all your active "extensions" ring. Anyone of the active extensions can take the call, leaving the others free to take or make another call.

    Typically, you are only logged in to one machine. If you had been offline when you log back in new voice mails are delivered. If three VM's were delivered and you listen to two and then go and log on to another PC with the same identity, you will receive a copy of the third voicemail you hadn't listened to. This means that listening to a voice mail clears the Skype server and confirms delivery of the message. Until you listen it will send you that VM every time you log in no matter where you log in. Once you listen it stops trying to follow you.

    How do you use this knowledge?
    If you want a central repository for all your VM then either just use one PC or leave that PC on at all times. Thus, if you are out of the office on a laptop, and normally use a desktop then leave your desktop on if you want to capture all the VM there. Listening on one won't delete the message from another.

    What are the implications?
    You could share VM on a partyline. It would be just like it happens now on the home answer machine. However, you would have to be always on... to share in all the messages.

    This creates a very efficient messaging server for Skype, purging messages in many cases as soon as they arrive. Unlike cellphone systems that request you to press 7 to delete or only save for 30 days. Skype simplifies this behavior. I'm sure all voice mail also remains encrypted. Thus the Skype is merely a delivery agent.

    It's useful to remember that Skype is unique as a IM system in that it doesn't log you out of one client when you log into another (like AIM, Yahoo, MSN). Also remember that your contact list now follows you. So no matter where or on which machine you log on... you will always have your buddy list.

    For Skype API Developers… a new release

    The latest release of the SkypeAPICOM Wrapper Version 1.0.0.18 is now available and packaged as an MSI (Microsoft Installer), which means it now auto installs into C:\Windows\System\ and register itself. Nice touch Jason.

    The new version 1.0.0.18 provides access to the new Skype API Conference feature and multi-Chat announced by Skype on March 17 and discussed in the Skype Journal.

    Not only does the new version self install and register the service it installs a much needed Help file. The "Help" file is located in your start menu or C:\Windows\help.

    Developer Jason Terando, (Skype User Name: carcass) says, “The new MSI will make it so developers can redistribute the DLL file in an organized manner”.

    It was also nice to see that Jason responded to Stuart’s “worry” post in such a quick fashion.

    It passed my tests with our own API Presence Exchange product and with SAM. I will continue testing...

    March 24, 2005

    Share of IM Market?

    Today's NY Times article reported that Skype has 2.8 million users in the US. Now households and users may not be quite the same thing. The following numbers for Instant Messenger shares via Business Week. Why don't we hear more about Skype and IM numbers? Has Skype hurt IM growth? Probably not, it is more likely to have grown the market. Are we nearing the point where 1 in 10 internet savvy US households has Skype?

    U.S. households using as primary IM provider Percent market share, 2004
    AIM 18.9 million 50.70%
    MSN 7.76 million 20.80%
    Yahoo! 9.07 million 24.30%
    Alternative 1.6 million 4.20%
    Source: The Yankee Group's 2004 Technologically Advanced Family Survey
    BusinessWeek Online

    Is Skype Flirting with SuperEva?

    In an announcement dated February 2, 2005 SuperEva an Italian dating and matchmaking site signed an agreement with Skype and is now hosting "Sirens and Studmuffins" with a "promo" prize being drawn June 17th. Apparently knocked up for Skype and Plantronics as a promotion it appears almost in stealth mode with less than 100 entrants.

    Sviluppato all’interno del sito www.sirensandstudmuffins.com powered by superEva.com, tale concorso viene promosso anche all’interno dei network televisivi delle universit inglesi e prevede da parte degli utenti di Skype e di superEva.com la compilazione di un form con i dati personali e alcune informazioni aggiuntive per “inquadrare” meglio ciascun partecipante agli occhi degli altri iscritti. DADA.NET

    Updating myself on Daum-Skype, seeing the reference to Jyve and Someonenew via the NY Times article this morning suggests it is time for a review of Skype, dating and social networking sites and opportunities. There are better ways for Skype to involve themselves and take social networking sites to a new level.

    One Korean Student and DaumSkype

    U.Yogeswaran is a student in Korea on Skype. He first contacted me some months ago. This post captures his observations on Skype in Korea. I was intrigued by his Daum comments (Skype - Daum Partnership Note this agreement was only signed two months ago!), interest in SkypeIn numbers and the perceived impact of video. Sometimes it is just useful to listen to what others say. These are his comments:

    My origin is India, came to Korea for higher studies. These are my observations about Skype.

    I am proud to say that in my school (Gwangju Institute of Science & Technology), I am the 1st person to introduce Skype to my friends, after that it spreads like a fire between international students. Skype is still not as popular as MSN and other messengers in Korea. The availability of internet is quite good, so I hope the usage of Skype will steadily increase.

    Until http://skype.daum.net/ arrived (Note Jan 21, 2005), Skype was not popular; the main reason was no Korean language website! In Korea people prefer Korean websites to English, and Duam is one of the most popular, but there is no advertisement or bold links to Skype in that website. (Note I found it in the navigation bar and there Daum-Skype appears to have profile pages).

    The main thing Skype lacks is video chatting, most people prefer webcam (But in my case, if the webcam reduce the voice clarity in Skype, I don’t prefer webcam). Also the interface, color of the Skype is not as attractive as other messengers like MSN, etc; there is no attractive impression at the 1st sight, which always influences the usage. And it should add some of the utilities like SMS too. Also students prefer to chat in IM than talking in schools because they cannot talk in public places, so the IM is as attractive as that of other messengers. An important aspect is Skype doesn’t have sufficient advertising, so it lacks popularity.

    Many people in Korea are using skype for fun, usually high school & university students, meeting strangers, especially foreigners and having a good experience with them. Maybe some time it may not be safe. Then they are very much interested in developing their spoken English & French through Skype.

    PDAs are not very popular in Korea, common people doesn’t have PDAs. The WiFi hotspots are only in developed places and there is no proper coverage! Also the fee is very expensive, so mobile skype usage is limited. Also the usage of the OS other than Windows like Linux, Mac are not in Korea; used only in educational institutes and in some developed industries.

    If skype becomes popular, then every business could use Skype for their customer utility applications. SkypeIN numbers in Korea could be a good thing, which will attract many business opportunities in Korea, maybe China, Japan & other near by countries could buy a lot of SkypeIN Korean numbers! Also Skype should provide the toll free skypeIN numbers for competitive price, so that many business people could prefer. If SkypeIn gains good usage, then Skype voicemail will also become useful. SkypeOut should also be advertised properly for business applications. Different types of Skype versions should be available, like server side for business applications & schools that could be applied to intercom communication systems.

    At present in Korea Skype is popular only between younger generations for having fun!

    A comment for reflection. When I looked at the DaumSkype site (which I can't read) "profiles" appear to be there. Rather than advertising, the next generation of "Skype" uptake advances are going to come from more developed social networking sites.

    NY Times on Skype Intimacy

    The New York Times catches up on Barlow's Intimate Planet post, providing a positive SkypeMe look at Skype and updates on statistics. Guess one satisfaction is my readers saw this all months ago!

    Skype says that it has over 2.8 million users in the United States and 30.6 million worldwide and that it is adding users at a rate of 155,000 a day. Skype's biggest competitor, Vonage, a paid VoIP service, has about 550,000 customers.

    But voice brings to life the other person in a way that typing cannot, like hearing Mr. Einkamerer laugh at my jokes. The instant-messaging environment is anonymous; with voice, you cannot hide from the other person.... It feels intimate because it is; more of the users' voices reach each other The New York Times

    See also "Hanging out online".

    Answer Machine Business Models

    The competitive tussle between Skype Answer Machines SAM and Pamela and the release of Skype Voice Mail is forcing ongoing strategy assessments for these early Skype Plug-in solutions.

    Pamela Systems followed the SAM upgrade with a few revisions of their own; extending the recording time (this is not a "chargeable" versions feature in my view) and a few minor changes. I believe when Pamela Systems releases their Standard version (now expected 5 Euro) it will offer one feature that can provide some extra utility; text message only answering. It's useful when you are already in a call, converting a inbound ring to a potential chat exchange. Still this is a feature Skype should build in. Rather than forward to Voice Mail or ignore call -- send chat instruction - user defined text.

    Observations:

    From a functionality point of view Skype's VM is simply a better approach. I've continued to watch these two solutions because the real demand is for "call recording" whether for podcasts or journalists etc. Again in time Skype could offer it. Buy a Skype recorder account, add that account name to your conference call, begins recording and both parties get a copy of the call as soon as the recorder is hung up. I'd think that's just another 5 Euro to the guys at Skype.

    The lesson here is it is very hard to make "money" on voice related add-on services. They are really core to Skype. By contrast Skype is asking / begging for text, presence, answering, location, etc. solutions by offering it's API.

    We have just finished the Pamela Basic 1.0a upgrade We have also finished Pamela Standard 1.1 and will release it shortly. Standard will have:

    - Recording of up to 4 hours
    - Visual display which messages played and which are new
    - Notification alerts if a contact status changes (with details)
    - Option to take call back to Skype
    - All Basic functions enabled

    Pamela Standard 1.1 for €5,00. This includes future upgrades as well as active support

    We will be releasing our third product, Pamela Professional Version mid/end April. This version will offer following additional features to Standard:

    - Unlimited recording time
    - Email forwarding (with proxy support)
    - Individual answer settings (greeting chat messages skype status notifications) per contact
    - Time scheduling
    - Call recording

    Professional will cost €15. People that have bought Standard will be able to upgrade for the price difference (€10).

    Pamela-Systems

    March 23, 2005

    Library Trialing Skype

    Nice story emerging with librarians trying to help distance learners with Skype. Carol Cooke is looking for other librarians --- via Library Stuff.

    Sheri Vokey writes:

    I want to integrate it into distance ed support here at the Libraries. If things go smoothly, I'll be offering it up as one more way for distance students to contact me (we don't have toll free here). InfoShare

    Von and Podcasting

    I meant to post this a week ago. It's a credit to Jeff Pulver and Carl Ford that there was a Podcasting session at VON. As VON --- VOICE --- is freed of telephony's shackles, the creativity of individuals is released and new avenues for expression are created. If I had one criticism of VON it would be that these "experiments" (the blogging panel was another) weren't understood by the "general audience". Podcasting really reframes "Voice" and how individuals put new tools to use. A couple of Telecom guys did turn up. The rest missed out on stretching their thinking.

    So this was my favorite session at VON and it took place almost afterhours.

    I turned up at the VON Podcasting session hosted by Scott Rafer, Eric Rice and Adam from WordPress and ended up in a long dinner session that also included James Seng and Carl Ford. While Scott and Eric were probably disappointed by the lack of a crowd, we had a wonderful broadranging session.

    Two clear agenda items came out for me. First was the demand and interest in Skype for Podcasting and thus making SkypeCasting easier. It was simply amazing how the discussion moved to Skype and recording Skype calls. There is a real demand for extracting SkypeVM and turning it into podcasts. These are currently just mini-briefs... now up to 10 minutes although I'm sure Skype can create solutions that provide a "longer" time capture. There are two areas where Skype can really turn up the heat in the Podcasting.

    First is enabling simplified capture of phoned in information. This format would be very similar to what Eric is doing with AudioBlog. He also tells me he is the "podcast" organizer and guru behind Weblog Inc's activities in this area.

    Second is to simplify the solution we outlined in SkypeCasting. Concurrently with the number of podcasters on macs --- Skype should consider offering a solution for this as well. We'll define one in another post. For capturing conversational exchanges the easiest solution is for Skype to enable a Podcast capability in a modified Voice Mail client. The downside is the current client doesn't have a stop / start function etc. Thus extra features are required. For example. I purchase with my skype account a recorder account / profile. Thus Skype opens a second profile for me. Note this doesn't need to be on my PC or running. It's just a client that I can call into I can bridge it in to any conference call. Whenever it is in a conference call it automatically text's both parties letting them know that a live recording is in progress. Just like the VM solution it is recorded on my PC and then uploaded to both parties at the end of the call.

    The other solution is to automate the Skypecasting solution.

    Separately, as the evening progressed.... I learned more and more about WordPress an open source blogging platform that has been challenging MT for some time. Many MT users migrated a year or so ago. As I listened I became more and more impressed. I've been disappointed in MT ever since they imploded on licenses last year. Recently I added a commercial license as well. However, frustrations still abound. I get more and more trackback spam, comment spam is controlled although hard to deal with. Then recently all the sites were consolidated under SixApart. Navigation has to be learnt all over again and I'm not sure that the forums and the information has the "vibrancy" that it had a couple of years ago. Listening to the WordPress points of difference I simply made a commitment to pay attention and download and install.

    New Skype Release 1.2.0.37

    Change log:

    23.03.2005 version 1.2.0.37
    feature: Central Contacts List
    feature: Voicemail
    feature: SkypeIn
    feature: Getting Started Wizard
    feature: Promote Add To Contacts
    feature: toolbar added to call tab
    feature: File Transfer - ability to select multiple files to send
    feature: Import/Export contactlist from/to vCard
    feature: API: possible to initiate conference
    feature: added exitsurvey when Skype is uninstalled
    feature: chat /alertson * /alertsoff

    There are many bug fixes.

    This looks like a worthwhile download. Release notes suggest voice quality is improved... hard to believ it could get better. :)

    March 22, 2005

    800 Replacement for Everyone?

    In the tech centric world of podcasting, the 800 number is dead. Is Skype the new emerging 800 number for everyone? TechAddition shares their details below. Not that different to other sites using Skype. However now with voice mail the utility has taken on a whole new meaning.

    Wouldn't it be cool if you could Skype your questions and comments to a techADDICTION answering machine and leave a message so Kevin and James could maybe even put it on the show? Live, er, recorded? Wouldn't that be COOL?

    Just Skype: techaddiction

    And yes, it IS cool. :)

    UPDATE: NOTE: If you don't want your name to be mentioned on the show or you would prefer not to have your voicemail on the show, please let us know. We'd love to have you and your questions on the podcast, but we certainly respect people's needs for privacy.
    ThePodcastNetwork