Skype Journal

Independently covering the Talk Revolution since 2003

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Dryburgh: What's after Skype? Intent.

eBay is preparing to spin-out Skype, setting it free to steer its own course. Almost six years ago Skype redefined realtime communications and changed the industry. Lee Dryburgh, the man behind the Emerging Communications Conference, shared some thoughts with me about his vision for what comes next. – Phil Wolff

Lee Dryburgh and cameraI spent many years thinking about telephony, seven days a week, in a way it “destroyed” my life in a mental health sense during those years trying to ascertain where it was going between 2005-2020. It was clear to me that what had existed for over a century and which today generates revenues that dwarf the Internet, was going to be surpassed and that we had already put one foot on the cliff edge. It’s the big reason I kicked off the Emerging Communications Conference & Awards, because no other event seemed to have enough inherent vision.

Where is it going?

First you’ve got the telephony application itself. Because of the exceptional widespread deployment of the telephone, it’s century long cultural embedment, extreme ease of use and very low barriers to usage, it’s not going away in a big way, at any time least soon. It’s far too big and you’ve got far too much inertia in and around it.

Relationships replaces Voice as the substrate in clients. 

However because its substantial list of deficiencies grows, what we are seeing emerging and what will gain ever further traction is software based voice-enabled, communication technologies. Interestingly voice may not be the “substrate” of these clients, “relationships” will be, both between people and things.

Second, we’ve got the economic model behind it. Even today, well over a hundred years since it’s original inception, we still have the same usage paradigms and economic models put in place at the time of the first electro-mechanical switches.

Now the keyword in all of this is “software.” Six years ago, the Skype software client was released. It was the harbinger of change to come. It called into question the need for very expensive dedicated underlying transport networks by pushing edge intelligence into the Codec layer to deal with less than ideal networks. It called into question the need for dedicated telecom hardware in the core network, by using the edge-clients to perform the work in a decentralised fashion. It called into question the inherent limited geographical structuring of telecom operators themselves; software does not face such physical and regulatory boundaries; distribution is relatively zero-cost; and worse still for the operator model, by it’s global footprint, it achieves unprecedented scale.

Looking forwards, we can consider Skype phase one.

Phase two is emerging on the horizon and it will have deeper impact yet. In fact, played out it will change social governance, market economics, how humans relate to each other and even the nature of geo-politics. It’s likely to have ramifications on all social order. In the long-term view, it will also be the “new” multi-trillion dollar market replacing much of what today is the multi-trillion-telephony market.

Phase two is built around an economic model that puts human time and attention at a premium as opposed to dedicated circuits, specialist hardware and personnel. It’s the opposite of what we experience today with telephony, where human time and attention is wasted; ringing, call queues, voice mail boxes, IVR trees, repetitious verbal transfer of static information such as credit card numbers, call transfers and such like.

And that’s just a quick C2B example. C2C has similar lunacy, for example needing to place a telephone call to request a single piece of discrete information or the other person’s location. The economic crisis experienced worldwide is likely to highlight such sources of great inefficiency.

Here is another angle to get you thinking, more and more calls originate from a number noted on a Website and yet when the call is placed, no information is passed with the call about what the context of the call. It’s lost, so each end has to orally work more at the beginning that would otherwise be necessary. Billions of minutes are needlessly wasted on a every day globally.

Phase two is about intention-based economics. It’s focused on fulfilling intentions and desires. Another way of putting it is we no longer need to care about network availability (i.e. “dial tone”), and reaching an endpoint (i.e. A telephone). Network availability and endpoint reachability is assumed. What we care about with intention based economics is human psychology and behaviour, both individual and in aggregate. I’m not saying we need to become psychologists and anthropologists. But what we need to build for is access to ever more personal information, i.e. about the human behind the endpoint. Privacy does not exist looking long-term. Ever more personal information is the new currency, which underlies intention-based economics, and people will increasingly trade it for free access to services.

If any of this seems abstract at the moment, think about what makes Google money, Ad Words. Google provides search free to the consumer in order to gain eyeballs (mass attention) and takes the search parameter to try and deduce intention. It then sells that attention and intention data upstream to advertisers. Google even has machines reading your emails in order to deduce your possible intentions and desires, which is why you may often find an eerily relevant ad above your Gmail account inbox. The underlying reason for the Android initiative surely has to be to gain access to better intention deriving data in order to sell upstream to advertisers.

Yet telecom networks receive vastly more human attention coming in from the edges and transit much more “intention data” than Google, in the form of telecom signaling. But it’s latent, not acted upon and thrown away. They actually throw away their most precious asset and plan to continue charging for their long-term least worthy asset (voice transmission).

To make the situation even worse, telecoms today is still charging downstream to the consumer, ignores money and wishes of upstream parties (like retailers, media companies for example). Because the telecom business model and regulation is pretty much hard nailed like the network itself, the bulk of telecom operators are not likely to be able to transition in time before other entrants move in who appreciate the new economics and who don’t have ball and chain legacy. New entrants and probably a third of telecom operators will transition successfully around phase two.

You’re probably wondering what phase two looks like from the point of view of applications? This is where things get very abstract and potentially the prose could get long-winded. But this is not to be unexpected since the foundation is in the abstract with the word “intention.” To try and get a flavour of the phase two application direction, imagine for a start that the demarcation lines between content, information access, entertainment, ecommerce unravel ever further and the result is intrinsically tied to an ever smarter fusion of more communication modalities. Now underpin that with attention and intention based economics.

Now dream a little.

Labels: , , , , ,

Monday, June 22, 2009

Roundup – Skype news

Yugma logo - on whiteYugma desktop sharing still hosts multiparty Skype meetings. New CEO tells TMC's Patrick Bernard this Skype partner is restarting after layoffs and generally winding down the company. From happier times, Skype Journal wrote up: Yugma Skype Edition: Cross Platform Desktop Sharing, Yugma Skype Edition Version 3: Fluid Collaboration, Yugma Skype Becomes Skype Certified. Yugma may avoid Convenos' dismal fate. Skype offered its own 1-to-1 desktop sharing this year, throwing independent developers under the bus to pursue WebEx market.

sangoma logoPrettyMay partners with Sangoma, one of Skype's oldest independent software developers, announced Sangoma, a VoIP hardware manufacturer, will sell their Skype PBX Gateway running PrettyMay Skype trunking software. Excellent distribution for PrettyMay, new markets and 4/5 stars for saving money. Sangoma can now compete more directly with VoSKY's Skype trunking systems, some of which distributed partnership with Skype.

truphone logoTruphone beats Skype to push notifications on the iPhone. Martin Bryant says the push service on iPhone 3.0 software lets people call you via truphone even if you're using another app. "If someone calls your Truphone number and you’re not using the app they’re prompted to leave a voicemail message. A notification is then pushed to your iPhone inviting you to listen to the recording."

number garage logoNumberGarage does for phone numbers what domain hosts do for domains. "NumberGarage™ empowers people to manage their phone numbers, with or without phone service, all from the NumberGarage™ Web site." Park and forward phone numbers, just like at GoDaddy.

1 millionGoogle reserves a million phone numbers from Level 3. Probably for Google Voice customers. Is that a weekend supply, like Apple iPhone 3G S sales?

TiVo logo - 2dCourts uphold TiVo patents on playing, pausing, rewinding streaming video. Do TiVo patents apply to voicemail/videomail too? Many mobile phones now offer some TiVo-like features for voice and video messaging.

skype logo - blue on whiteSkype cuts SkypeOut rates to Turkey mobiles and landlines. Turkey's landline prices are falling toward Skype's world rate of about €1 per hour. Meanwhile telcos in other countries raised rates a little: Albania – Mobile, Benin, Comoros and Mayotte, El Salvador – Mobile, Malawi and Malawi – Mobile, Swaziland, Togo, Wallis and Futuna.

eComm Conference & Awards logoeComm, The Emerging Communications Conference 2009b (Amsterdam), issued a Call For Speakers. It's a boring read, so they really need your creative, mind-blowing, insightful, world changing, quintessentially European, future bending proposals.

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Should Skype clients be Wave containers?

Last week Google announced Wave, a pre-alpha browser application project. The experience is like instant messaging but with the extensibility and variety you might find in facebook or OpenSocial applications. Wave can be highly decentralized, like email, with Wave servers hosted by any person or company that cares to. imageWave clients run in browsers. (Good to know: Skype desktop clients have tiny browsers inside.)

Extensibility makes a container useful in more ways. Like adding new tools to your Swiss Army knife or multitool. Apps could change what goes on inside the chat. We will be able to combine them in interesting ways. To surround chat with useful information about people. To enrich ways we discover people to talk with, to initiate conversations, to conduct those conversations using the right tools for that conversation, and to use the history of those conversations meaningfully.

What if Skype chat had Wave inside?

Wave solves several Skype problems:

  1. One size doesn't fit all. People are diverse. So are the ways we want to talk. Skype is mastering the middle ground, ignoring the long tail of experience demand.
  2. Skype is closed. Promoting the Skype namespace so non-Skype users can chat with Skypers should increase demand for access to Skype services. New blood to boost the number of people in the Skype network. 
  3. Skype isn't developer-bait. Skype might siphon off Wave talent. Opening up Skype to developers gives them immediate access to a world market, a great opportunity to bring them in to the Skype developer program. Done well, you might do without giving up control of Skype's added value.
  4. Skype doesn't run in browsers. Waving the Skype desktop client could lead to a browser-based rich Internet application, a Skype that runs in a browser without a 20MB download.

The flip side is opportunity:

  1. Skype meets more needs (lock-in in more markets).
  2. Skype attracts new customers (faster word of mouth).
  3. Skype attracts developers (lighter platform, bigger market).
  4. Skype runs everywhere (not just in Skype clients).

What would you like to see Skype become?

tags: , , , , , , , ,

Call me at +1-510-455-4384, Skype me, follow @skypejournal and @Phil Wolff.
Visit our Skype Journal private roundtable, one of the longest running public Skype chats.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Thursday, April 30, 2009

Can digital pipes handle swine flu epidemic spikes?

Pandemics change human behavior for millions of people. Our networks may not be ready for those changes.

avisoimportante-Chupacabras Just stay home. Wash your hands. Advice from the US CDC for people at risk of the 2009 swine flu. Mexican authorities urge avoiding face-to-face contact in many-to-many places like hospitals, museums, theaters, cinemas (releases of X-Men Origins and Star Trek are postponed), churches, sports events, public markets.

importantnotice-Chupacabras Working at Home. While television (or streaming video) might substitute in sports and music events, bringing other work home is harder.

  • Can mobile phones and the Internet create alternatives for information, education, service, and entertainment workers?
  • Can employers keep workers home?
  • Can employers quickly offer full digital command, communications, collaboration, coordination, and control services to sites scattered throughout a city?

maskedsoldier-Chupacabras-Online communities swarm in response to emergencies and threats. 9-11, Tsunami relief, Katrina, Mumbai invasion, Southern California wildfires had four stages.

  1. Spreading alarms ("hey did you see?") through many online media to trigger swarming. today, this includes tags and #hashtags, improving discoverability and transmissibility of the event and the event's memes. People want to know more. As people flock to the news, they create an overwhelming amount of repetition and echo and noise. So people start... 
  2. Organizing to improve/concentrate/filter information. People want to make sense of the spew. At the start people create new topical blogs, email lists, facebook forums, YouTube channels. Volunteers transcribe television and radio reports, retweet headlines and commentary, timelines of government responses. In short filtering, digestion, and meaning step in. Then people want to help other people (and themselves). So you see
  3. Online serves offline. Volunteers build specific services connecting online news/community to local people/places/activities. For Tsunami relief I participated in an instant call center via Skype community volunteers. Other services put together online databases of victims, or geomashups of hotspots, or fundraising projects, or medical information.
  4. Aftermath. People are helped, most of the online world goes back to their lives, and some of the legacy systems persist to serve those still concerned or affected by the event.

maskcrowd-Chupacabras-

By contrast, people shun common places and take refuge in their homes in a biological outbreak/epidemic/pandemic.

This creates new problems.

  • Stage Leapfrogging. Surprise! Step 1 (alarming, swarming) will take place in hours. You'll move immediately to Step 2, managing information overload. You could wake up having missed your chance to shape your community's and business's response. Or first access to preventive measures. 
  • Social Infrastructure Demand Scales. While millions are affected by most major disasters, pandemics could affect hundreds of millions, especially those in big cities where people congregate. Is twitter ready for 100 million new users? Facebook? CDC.gov? Amazon and Google cloud computing?
  • Infrastructure Demand Shifts Home. Capacity is in the wrong place. Are the nation's ISPs ready to move data to residential pipes at workplace speeds, without residential caps, all day, every day? How fast can mobile carriers supplement residential coverage? Who would fund this buildout? Can we beef up the last mile faster than an epidemic spreads? Can we allocate resources based on where an epidemic hits first and worst, instead of using pure market forces?
  • Cannot Filter Meaningful Signal from Abundant Noise. Today's tools don't help people consistently and reliably pick the vital, life changing information from the ordinary. So you'll miss product recalls, medical updates, neighborhood alerts in the lossy spew of mailing lists, social updates, and newsfeeds. Would you trust your family's life to a #hashtag ?
  • Local Focus Without Local Filters. Many of our systems depend on hundreds or thousands of people looking intently at one topic. What happens when we have must hyperlocalize news and community? The ratio of participants-per-topic falls fast as people focus on their own lives, their own work, their own neighborhoods. Does your block have enough people updating the network so the social network benefits kick in? We clearly don't have tough, accurate filters/readers to help us focus by:
    • Geography (streets, blocks, buildings, neighborhoods),
    • Topic (all those people who might have congregated at baseball games, pubs, museums, city hall), and
    • Occupation (by employer, workplace, team, process, project, agency)
    • Clinic (chains of information, care, supplies, volunteers, alerting)
  • Service Gaps. The digital divide has dramatic health effects on the poor, homeless, and underclasses. Tens of millions of the vulnerable are without mobile phones, email, or any frequent internet access. How do you connect offline people to online services?

What can we do to prepare?

See also:

photos credit cc:by Randal Sheppard 

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Thursday, April 16, 2009

2009 Q1 Google Earnings Slides

The face of the Great Recession. From Google's quarterly conference call

image

A maturing market? Or a contracting market?

image

Weakening seems to be all US for now.

image The good news is that as the economy tanked, and per-unit ad values fell, Google spent less on advertising to bring in traffic.  

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Friday reading

me

The New York Times logoI'm in the New York Times coverage of Google Voice. Quoted correctly (yay!) but before my own column on the subject came out (d'oh!). Google has some truly delightful advantages in the race to become the world's largest communications company. 

under

Australia's Telestra keeps Nokia N85 inside the walled garden, keeps Skype out. A year without growth leaves them cautious, even when Skype offers to pay.

nz Yellow logo by you.New Zealand's Yellow partners with Skype. Search through the Skype Directory and call most nz companies for free until June 10. 

the future

Foresight Institute gets a new president. Skype me (evanwolf) if you want to come to Dr. Hall's Sunday reception in Palo Alto. We'll all be talking molecular manufacturing, nanotechnology and the singularity.

Nokia shares its vision. Smartphones rising. Death of patience. Rewarding engagement. Personal expression. New learning economy. Clickable world. Personal relevance. A good summary of forces driving the interplay between mobile technology, industry dynamics, and human behavior.

the present

cdc logoOne in four drop landlines in some states according to a US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) study. Turning to mobiles, an act of belt-tightening. Q. Of those who switch to mobile, how many have unlimited flat-rate data plans, favorable to Skype?

CRM Over Voice: Using Voice in New Ways for Service Providers to Retain Subscribers and Strengthen Brand. White paper by analyst Jon Arnold for Mobivox. The cool stuff starts on page 4. Speech recognition + VoIP + SaaS = Contextual CRM, creating touch points that add value to the customer journey. Jon explains why it's good and how to build it, using Mobivox as an example.

VoSKY sells Skype trunking to Majorcan hotel chain. Attach a box to your PBX and your staff doesn't even know they are calling through the Skype network at lower rates. 

Larry Dignan shows why mobile developers migrate from Symbian to RIM and Mac OS X. Growth and share favor the Bold. And iPhone.

the past

Transcript of Skype's Jonathan Christensen's talk about speech quality at the Emerging Communications Conference last week. History as prelude to something new?

gig

Benjamin Leviton seeks VoIP help: "I have a Brekeke SIP proxy server. I am looking for someone to remote on to my desktop, log into its interface and config my carriers with the proxy server. Also check the interface of Polycom phone and make sure it is working properly with the SIP proxy server." Contact:  +1-917-273-5808, ben@capitalfinanceusa.com, yahoo IM gcc644@yahoo.com, or skype:levtop.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, January 31, 2009

Google's Three Opportunities for FCC2009

Emerging Communications 2009Emerging Communications' Lee Dryburgh interviewed Richard Whitt, Google's Washington telecom and media counsel.

Whitt sees three opportunities for Google and the emerging communications community.

        • The stimulus package. It may incent next generation broadband.
        • Unlocking more of the government wireless spectrum. So it can be put to use.
        • Defining a national broadband policy.

If you like Lee's Richard Whitt interview, Whitt will speak at eComm09 in San Francisco.

NOTE: While the early bird discount ends today, you can still get 20% off with your 'skypejournal' discount code. See you there.

tags: , , , , ,

Talk with Phil Wolff on Twitter or FriendFeed or on Skype.
Follow Skype Journal on twitter

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Splashtop preloads Skype

Splashtop first screen

"With Splashtop, you can access the Internet and your favorite applications seconds after turning on your PC."

"Be online seconds after you turn on your PC. Why wait for Windows to load when you could be surfing the web right away!"

Whether it's Windows 7 or Android, people launch Skype on startup. Connecting to the network gets you "Skype dial tone," so you can make and take Skype calls and chats and sync your history. I want Splashtop on my next laptop.

tags: , , ,

Talk with Phil Wolff on Twitter or FriendFeed or on Skype.
Follow Skype Journal on twitter

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Monday, January 12, 2009

Skype Surpasses 15 Million Concurrent Users!

While on Skype this morning, I noticed something I think is astonishing! 15+ million simultaneous online users!

This is a huge feat that the Skype team should be very proud of.

An a related note: Skype just launched Skype 2.8 for Mac and some versions for Android as well.

Update: Looks like Skype just posted about this as well.

This is a guest post written by Jason Harris, an internet telephony writer and enthusiast. To follow him further, read his blog.



Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Skype at CES 2009: Initial Steps Towards Liquid Communication

At a Skype's CES 2009 press conference today recently appointed COO Scott Durschlag provided the first hints of a vision statement for Skype under its new executive team along with some initial software offerings that hint at the direction Skype is taking towards "liquid communications" or "Skype Whenever, Wherever".

In leading up to the new software announcements, Scott made a few points about Skype's recent accomplishments and focus going forward:
  • Skype now delivers 8% of the world's telecom minutes through clients that now support 28 languages
  • New software will drive a liquid experience on the desktop, web, TV and mobile devices
  • A key goal is to liberate the Skype experience from a captive device (desktop) to more user aware devices (mobile, TV as well as embedded into appliances)
  • 41% of Skype calls on Christmas day involved video, only to be surpassed at 47% on New Years day.
  • New software offerings have to pass a bar of four basic criteria:
    • high call quality
    • super simple user interface
    • sensitivity to power management issues
    • security

He then went on to talk about new software offerings:

  • New desktop clients: Skype for Mac 2.8 (launched as beta at Mac World Monday), Skype for Windows 4.0 (with a February release date)
  • Release of Skype Lite, a thin client for Java-enabled mobile phones with Skype for Android to be available within a few days on Android Market on T-Mobile's G1TM and Skype Lite general availability in the U.S. (in addition to several countries previously announced) resulting in Skype availability on over 100 mobile smartphones.
  • Internally developed new Skype "SILK" audio codec which is twice as efficient with respect to bandwidth requirements for the audio and video experience.
  • Skype for Mobile Internet Devices with a demonstration on a couple of MID platforms. (Update: access download information here.)
  • Skype for Mac 3.0 to be available by year end with the feature set of Skype 4.0 for Windows.
This afternoon Phil and I spent an hour with Scott discussing the restructuring, support issues, the TOM Skype Breach and how Skype will work with its developer partners to provide a win-win direction for the development and marketing of partner applications. These topics will be the subject of future posts over the next week.

First impression: it's the first event where a senior Skype executive has provided in a public forum an outline of its vision, guidelines for achieving that vision and how it wants to work in the real time communication and IP-based conversation space. The real challenge now lies in the execution.

Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

CES rumor: Skype Lite for Android Mobile Devices

Working to confirm Skype’s Skype Lite will be available for the Android mobile operating system.

UPDATE: TechChuck seems to be quoting an embargoed CNET story no longer online:

"Skype announced on Wednesday the forthcoming release of Skype Lite for Google Android and other Java-enabled phones. Skype Lite marks the communication company's first native VoIP client for Java. Skype is submitting the app to Google's Android Market on Thursday morning, though it could take Google a few days to offer it for download."

Technorati tags: , , , , ,

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Monday, January 5, 2009

Access Your Skype Contacts via Truphone

Over the past few years we have seen the evolution of several conversation communities, some simply employing instant messaging; others employing both instant messaging and voice. Skype is the primary example with its support of IM, voice and video as well as auxiliary features such as file sharing (and, as announced tonight, basic screen sharing) but we are also seeing these services diffuse into Google, via GTalk's voice and chat capability, MSN Live via Live Messenger, and, in spite of its trying to define who they are, Yahoo.

Truphone is a mobile voice calling service that I have used for a couple of years from a Nokia N95-1; it became critical in a situation I encountered in Germany two years ago. I have liked both the quality of the voice calls as well as the user interface, especially its use of the device's native address book for initiating a call. While they have had some hiccups with their recent product launches, Truphone has become the leader in providing low cost calling from the iPhone while breaking the carrier barrier via Apple's App Store. I will soon be reporting on Truphone Anywhere for BlackBerry. Now, under recently appointed CEO Geraldine Wilson, Truphone is making a move to grow their user base rapidly by leveraging the user bases of other services.

This evening at the MacWorld Showstoppers event Truphone announced an enhanced Truphone for iPhone providing connectivity to these four conversation communities. Supporting both instant messaging and voice conversations, voice calls to, say, Skype contacts are free provided they go over a WiFi connection. Calls to these communities can also be made over a carrier's 3G network, usually at the cost of a local call. In addition Truphone is providing access to Twitter as one additional messaging service accessible via Truphone's iPhone application.

In my interview this evening with new Truphone CEO Geraldine Wilson, she pointed out:
  • Using Skype as an example, Truphone's enhancements set up an appropriate Skype client on a Truphone gateway and complete the call to the Skype contact, taking advantage of Skype's peer-to-peer architecture such that there are no resulting termination charges.
  • By introducing instant messaging, Truphone is recognizing the key role IM is taking on in IP-based conversations where a conversation may start over a chat session and migrate to a voice session if deemed appropriate.
  • Truphone sees the introduction of these enhancements as a key to building the Truphone user community; Truphone generates revenue through offering low cost calling to/from the landline and mobile PSTN network.
  • Truphone is looking at adding BlackBerry and Android to their supported platforms for this service over the next few months. Key here are devices that support an application store in order to make user access to these services simple and trivial.
  • To avoid high roaming charges it is recommended that Truphone for iPhone be used either over a WiFi connection anywhere worldwide but only over a user's home country 3G carrier.
  • These new features go live on next Monday, January 12.
Some outstanding questions:
  • Given that the Truphone application needs to be active for conversations, how will this work when other applications are open? Currently if I have Truphone as the open application on my iPhone, I can receive free Truphone calls and my presence will be indicated to other Truphone for iPhone users if I am in their "Favorites" tab. However, if I am in another iPhone application, I cannot receive "free" Truphone calls over WiFi; nor is my presence indicated to others. I look forward to seeing how the enhanced Truphone handles Instant Messaging when Truphone is not the "open" application on the iPhone. This is where BlackBerry's full multi-tasking capability is a major advantage over the iPhone.
  • Calling Skype contacts involves providing your SkypeID and password. What security is in place to maintain the confidentiality of this information. What other security aspects are compromised as a result of placing the calls via a connection to a gateway that supports the caller's Skype client.
  • What is Skype's reaction to having Truphone siphon off what could otherwise potentially be SkypeOut revenues while leveraging the Skype user base and using the "free" aspect of Skype? We know Skype is working to launch mobile phone applications, probably this week at CES. With iSkoot and the Skypephone on 3's networks, as we learned at last year's eComm 2008 iSkoot presentation, a portion of carrier revenues are shared between Skype and iSkoot.
A major step forward in making low cost calls worldwide, Truphone's moves once again emphasize that WiFi is becoming an ever growing alternative connection option to making wireless calls. At the same time it will be interesting to see how the business model plays out in a world where the cost of voice calling continues to move towards zero.

GigaOm: Truphone Brings Skype to iPhone and iPod Touch

Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, January 1, 2009

Phil Wolff's 26 incriminating 2009 Skype Predictions

Last year's Jim Courtney's 2008 predictions and mine
Oakland California's local fortune cookie factoryIn 2009:
  1. MacWorld sucks without Steve Jobs.
  2. Steve Jobs steps down as Apple CEO.
  3. Skype brings back Skypecasts with a new feature: with one click, introduce spammers, con artists, and sexy webcam girls to each other.
  4. Skype for Neocortex. Mood based on serotonin levels. Very high quality audio and video by tapping directly into the optic nerve and auditory system. Some side effects.
  5. Skype for Lovers. Extension of Skype 4.1. Just one buddy to dial. No interruptions. Ultrasimple UI: click the heart.
  6. Skype's new platforms have more active developers than BT Ribbit. More than Google Android. Fewer than Apple iPhone.
  7. Litigation. 1530 sleep deprived patients sue Skype for keeping them up late.
  8. Google Central will be exciting.
  9. Google Video Talk adds multiparty video.
  10. The Emerging Communications Conference (eComm) will sell out.
  11. Yahoo! fires thousands of people. Decimates the messenger team. Hires a new executive team. Reorganizes. Again.
  12. Skype introduces multiparty video. The kids love it. WebEx hates it.
  13. Skype for Asterisk gets video call support. Dating sites love it.
  14. Skype for WoW builds on Skype for Asterisk. The raiders love it. 
  15. Skypephone comes to the Americas via partnership with with US mobile carriers. Wal-Mart will carry it. Nothing for Canada.
  16. 3 INQ1 sales will cut into 3 Skypephone sales in the UK.
  17. U.S. Mobile Carterfone rules (to free mobile phones from carrier contracts) will be considered by the FCC.
  18. VoIP falls from telecom jargon. Even VoIP bloggers stop using the term. The public starts using Skype as a generic name for internet talk.
  19. eBay's auction businesses will do well in tough times, better in the second half of the year.
  20. Skype will make $630 million in FY2009.
  21. Peak Skype usage will top 18 million simultaneous users.
  22. Skype will serve 23 billion minutes in 2009Q4.
  23. Skype scores product placements in:

  24. Skype issues new krypto since its old cryptographic source code escaped from TOM-Skype control
  25. Skype Video for Mobile. Skype buys a streaming video service for smart mobile camera phones.
  26. China approves SkypeIn and SkypeOut.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

free and brainless

brainless by you.

Hmm. Maybe it’s time for Skype to launch Skype Mail with Skype video built in?

Labels: , , , ,

Saturday, December 13, 2008

Wishlist: Skype for Android?

Allow Skype to operate, as with the current Window mobile devices. Anything that iPhone refuses to offer, is a good offering point. - Caffè

Fifth most popular request for "Suggest an Android Application" on Google Moderator. Tetris is first.

tags: , , , ,

Follow Phil Wolff on Twitter or FriendFeed or on Skype.
Follow Skype Journal on twitter

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Google adds two-way, free SMS to Gmail

Announced yesterday. Uses the GTalk chat system. US only for now. Free for you, but each "Enter" you make counts as a text to the person on the phone. Hands-on write-up on VentureBeat. Skype offers SMS (although not in Beta 4 for Windows) for a fee and outbound only.

tags: , , , , ,

Friend Phil Wolff on Twitter or FriendFeed or on Skype.
Follow Skype Journal on twitter

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Will Sony layoffs affect Skype distribution?

Skype software runs on the Sony PSP 2000/3000 and Sony Mylo, perhaps on the Playstation 4 some day. Sony Corporation announced they are setting free 8000 employees and 8000 contractors from the 160,000 employee company. The decimation and plant closings should affect Sony's semiconductor, recording media, and television manufacturing most.

We won't know for until next year how this will affect products that can extend Skype's reach.

See also:

tags: , , , , , , ,

Follow Phil Wolff on Twitter or FriendFeed or on Skype.
Follow Skype Journal on twitter

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, December 2, 2008

Brand Value: Skype, iPhone, Google

I took a look at The Brand Bubble's BrandAsset Valuator (BAV), "the world's largest database of brand perceptions." Market research data visualization from Young & Rubicam Group.

This valuator compares four attributes: brand strength through differentiation and relevance, brand stature through esteem and knowledge.

11882@11881_36fe39f69dfa5cc019aed84dc4d183f0

Here's how they define the terms:

  • D. Energized Differentiation. A brand's unique meaning, with motion and direction. Relates to margins and cultural currency.
  • R. Relevance. How important the brand is to you. Relates to consideration and trial.
  • E. Esteem. How you regard the brand. Relates to perceptions of quality and loyalty.
  • K. Knowledge. An intimate understanding of the brand. Relates to awareness and consumer experience.

So I compared three global brands we know and love: Skype, the Apple iPhone, and Google.

11876@11875_bd42cf66a38088520f9891aa627cd42d

You can see they each score well on Energized Differentiation. There's nothing else like Skype, iPhone, or Google.

Skype and iPhone are both much less relevant to the average consumer than Google. Google is well understood and used by many more people.

Esteem and Knowledge both show a similar pattern: the brands with more experience and time have more stature in the minds of consumers. 

The BAV compares strength to stature in the next chart. You want to be in the upper-right quadrant with Google and eBay.

11879@11878_1ccd26c81381a41f11207281bc2436ca

Skype is moderate strength, low stature. So while Skype is defining its unique value proposition well, people don't feel they know or respect it. That will come with education, hands on, and time.

What three things should consumers learn about Skype in 2009? What can Skype do with its product strategy to move from the upper left to the upper right?

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Friday, November 28, 2008

Fring lays off 10, shows Skype's partnership with iSkoot pays

So Fring goes from 50 to 40 personnel. Big whoop. This is less a sign of trouble than of prudence. While the Fring layoff surprised Jan Geirnaert, Om Malik thinks it looks weak. It looks capital-conserving to me in light of the new economy.

Skype's clout matters in this space.

Fring and EQO and iSkoot all courted Skype executives for a partnership. Only iSkoot got the nod, which led to their becoming the software behind Skype's profitable 3 Skypephone and profitable relationships with carriers.

Skype and 3 solved iSkoot's need for distribution, capital for PSTN-Skype gateway operations, and traffic monetization. Fring must to leap those barriers on its own. Maybe you can help: Nominate Fring for the Crunchies 2008 award.

fring for iphone in the app store by you.

Fring's popular software lets you access many Skype features on your mobile phone, including Apple iPhones, Google Androids, and Nokia Symbian smartphones.

A Fring spokesperson wrote about Fring's 400% growth this last year, now at 400 thousand new accounts monthly:

The monthly increase is a result of a number of things - the continued viral growth in fringsters now active in over 220 territories globally, our phenomenally successful iPhone launch which took us to the Number 1 free AppStore download in markets worldwide within twelve hours of launch, a number of new product releases and handsets supported, and our overall business development effort which includes items such as the Mobilkom A1 deal.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Interview with Julien Decot of Skype

Christopher Smith of Relevantly Speaking interviewed Julien Decot, Director of Strategy for Skype, at the >play Conference last week. Rough transcript follows, emphasis mine.

Q. Hey, it's Christopher Smith here for Relevantly Speaking. We're in Berkeley at the Haas School of Business. We're at the play conference and we're talking with Julian from Skype.

You've got a really enviable position there at Skype. you're a director of strategy, which means you have the ability to see the future, move the company into particular directions. Where are you going right now?

JD. The beauty of working for Skype is the breadth of opportunities you look at is very very wide. I'll give you a few examples. Skype could get into SMBs or enterprise. Skype could move more aggressively into mobile. Skype could get into the web. So there's a flurry of opportunities. And my job is to navigate the ones we should go after first knowing we're only a 500 [person] company.

So a few things that says...

One is: mobility is a big deal for us. There's tremendous appetite from our users to use Skype on the mobile. We don't want just to take the experience on the desktop into mobile. We want to invent something that's very unique to mobile and complements the desktop really nicely.

And also we think, even if it doesn't sound super sexy, just improving the basics of the service making it into the next level is a big deal for us. The best example is video calling in high def for everyone. We think that's really exciting, for example, and we're working very hard at this.

Q. You just released a desktop device to assist in that.

JD. We work with ASUS as a partner. They built the first Skype specific video phone, for example, which allows you, for I think it's a $200 device in the US, to get very simple video calling capabilities from your home without having a computer or anything else. That's one example of things we think are pretty cool.

About Google Video

Q. Last week Google comes out with Gmail Chat and Video in there. Do you find yourself in a defensible position there? Do you think Skype already has a very significant head start?

JD. Every time Google enters a space you have to watch out. They're big and they're very good and they innovate really fast. First thing I'll say we're not very surprised, that's something we've been expecting for a while. We're surprised it took so long.

We think it's a good product, we think the quality is good, it's not great, it's good, a nice implementation.

We think it also validates our idea that video is a big deal. And it's so early that everyone who can come with us and sort of help evangelize the fact that video calling is free for everyone and that it works is good.

Of course it's going to force us to get better and better, but I wouldn't say it's going to change our course. we're going to watch them. That's a company we have a lot of respect for in general.

Search

Q. Discoverability seems to be a common theme in a lot of the conferences we've been attending, the problem of finding both people or audiences for content. How are you guys approaching that problem?

JD. That's a very big question. It totally depends on what you're looking for, if you're looking for content or people.

We spend a lot of time helping you find people. it's a big deal for us to find someone you can communicate with. And linking people is a big deal for us because we're in the communication business.

Finding content is not our business. We'll definitely leverage third parties to do it. We'll let third parties get into Skype, to allow this to happen. We have for example the ability to attach a video mood message to your profile. So we worked with partners; you can attach a video to your message and if I'm connected to you I can click on that video and watch a video clip. That's the kind of thing we're going to do but it's mostly about driving and triggering conversation.

Future?

Q. So looking around the corner what should I anticipate from Skype?

JD. Great mobile applications, across platforms. I don't want to announce anything but look around all the key platforms are coming up. We'll be on there very soon with something pretty radical I think.

Expect the video and voice quality to improve significantly. So expect very very awesome video quality very very soon. And expect a few surprises. If you're a Mac user you'll have a few surprises pretty soon.

Q. Any announcements about the Apple platform?

JD. Come to MacWorld and you'll know more.

See also:

tags: , , , ,

Follow Phil Wolff on Twitter or FriendFeed or on Skype.
Follow Skype Journal on twitter

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Friday, November 21, 2008

Did Google's iPhone app learn from Goog411?

Google's new iPhone Google Mobile App uses speech recognition. So does their directory assistance service, 1-800-GOOG-411 (1-800-466-4411). Is it a big leap to imagine that one learned from the other? Especially since Mobile App has a US English bias. Google's seemingly eclectic talk family is coming together.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Friday, November 14, 2008

GMail Voice and Video Chat: Threading Voice and Video Into Email Dialogues

Earlier this week the GMail weblog announced GMail voice and video chat; basically they are designed to add voice and video modes to an email thread; from the GMail blog post:
... today we're launching voice and video chat -- right inside Gmail. We've tried to make this an easy-to-use, seamless experience, with high-quality audio and video -- all for free. All you have to do is download and install the voice and video plugin and we take care of the rest. And in the spirit of open communications, we designed this feature using Internet standards such as XMPP, RTP, and H.264, which means that third-party applications and networks can choose to interoperate with Gmail voice and video chat.
This afternoon I had an opportunity to try it out with Hudson Barton; publisher of the Borderless Communicator weblog and tracker of "Real Skype Users". We had a 20 minute conversation using my Logitech QuickCam Pro for Notebooks on a Wiindows laptop and the webcam on Hudson's MacBook. There are two viewing sizes available: a 225 x 140 window inside the GMail tab of a Firefox (or other browser) session and an optional pop-up window that goes to 430 x 270. We were only able to determine that it provides a "letterbox" 1.6 width-to-height ratio (as opposed to the 1.33 ratio of "standard" video), but not the frame size or frame rate actually being transmitted over the Internet. As for CPU usage, the "googletalkplugi.exe" was using between 10% and 17% of my CPU. With no accessible statistics along the line of Skype's option to display call statistics, it was not possible to drill down further. Both audio and video quality were clear and crisp - quite acceptable for a basic one-to-one conversation. Echo cancellation was apparent; Hudson was using the native speakers and mic of his MacBook with no perceivable echo..

It's definitely not up to the feature set of Skype but here's where it fits in:

  • GMail certainly has a large user base, same order of magnitude as Skype.
  • It's easy to forward your standard POP/IMAP email account to GMail; I use this feature both for the resulting search capability and the available access to GMail on multiple devices, including smartphones.
  • It provides real time conversation mode options for GMail threads being read on a PC. While reading an email and running the cursor over the sender's name, an option pops up to respond to the email message by email, Chat or Voice/Video based on the sender information as shown in the graphic above.
I would classify GMail Voice and Video Chat as a very mild competitor to Skype, suitable for basic "free" voice and video as a conversation enhancer. There's no way to establish or check audio and video settings; there's no access to the PSTN; we are not aware of the security level of the conversations. While the video is quite good, it certainly does not meet Skype's High Quality Video standards. It's a perfect example of embedding voice and video into an application as a feature but it's not a standalone real time conversation software application. When I consider the rejuvenation of Global IP Solutions and look at its customer base, I can foresee many other forthcoming instances of embedded voice and video as a feature within an application.

Note: as for the installation issues that Aliza encountered, I simply went to the URL suggested in the GMail weblog post and installed the plug-in (with the browser open). But then you have to restart your browser (in my case Firefox); initially the "video availability indicators" (as represented in the graphic above) were not present but I had to head out from my office at that point. When I came back to my PC four hours later, they had appeared. Chat pixel dust from the (Google) cloud in the interim is my only explanation. At the time of writing this post, its availability should have spread to many GMail accounts by the usual Google osmosis process.

Full disclosure; the author has had previous first hand experience with what was thought to be an application but turned out to be a feature. Quarterdeck's mid-90's effort at building a web browser as an application was thwarted when Microsoft decided to make its web browser (aka MS Internet Explorer) a feature within the Windows operating system.

Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , ,

Thursday, November 6, 2008

iSkoot Scores a New $19MM Financing Round

This evening iSkoot, the service that provides Skype access from smartphones, announced they had received a new $19 million venture financing round to build out and bring to market a new suite of mobile communications services. Recently iSkoot acquired Social IM, who is in the beta stage of producing a desktop Instant Messaging client linking real time communications and notifications to social networks. No further details have been released but obviously both their existing financing partners and one new partner feel there is a significant potential.

Update: VentureBeat reports that the financing relates to a forthcoming AT&T service offering "an array of Web services to users of its low-end phones — the majority of its phones, which don’t have the iPhone’s powerful features. The services will include things like social networking, email, RSS feeds and eventually services like Twitter."

In addition to their smartphone service, iSkoot also provides the firmware behind the Skypephone, available through the Hutcheson Whampoa 3 carrier in the U.K., six other European countries, Hong Kong and Australia. According to Tech Crunch over 300,000 Skypephones are now in service. However, their recently launched iSkoot for Android appears to have encountered a rougher road; Andy speculates they may have launched prematurely to meet the G-1 launch date. I'm sure we'll see upgrades to address the outstanding issues.

Personally I have iSkoot running on my BlackBerry Bold, largely to keep current on my Skype chat sessions when away from my office, and have experienced it on the 8820 as well as a Nokia N95. Look forward to learning more about the services whose launch is being supported by this new funding round in today's somewhat rough economy. At least there's still support for innovation in the real time conversation space.

Tags: , , ,

Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, October 30, 2008

Two more reasons why SightSpeed is good for Logitech

Video cameras are being built into everything. Phones, monitors and nearly every new laptop. Logitech buying SightSpeed marks the end of the generic webcam add-on market, as Jim Courtney wrote up yesterday. Or the beginning of the end, at least.

Logitech can sell its high-end webcam technology to laptop and mobile OEMs like Dell, HP, Lenovo, Acer, Asus and Nokia, Samsung, Sony Ericson, Motorola, Qualcomm.

Logitech Video Inside. With Carl Zeiss Optics. With SightSpeed MultiParty Video. And Skype High Quality Video.

SightSpeed's white-label distribution has been effective, accounting for many more users than its own brand. Logitech could very well become a Dolby Labs for personal video, licensing the best quality video features, and de facto standards for video, to the world's devices.

Logitech wants freemium marketing power. Free video calling entices newbies who pay later for multiparty, higher quality experiences. This is a branding and customer relationship program that could spill over to Logitech's hardware products. It may also be Logitech's strongest relationship with end consumers since most of Logitech's sales go through resellers. SightSpeed's own revenue stream is a nice bonus to the strategic value of direct customer relationships.

A larger theme is synergy between realtime social networks and devices. Skype and Skypephones. Twitter and mobiles. Gtalk and Android. And now SightSpeed and Logitech.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, October 25, 2008

great googly moogly

nude women anywhere by you.

(have you seen non-sexual skype spam?)

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, October 23, 2008

iSkoot Available Through Android Market on T-Mobile's Newly Launched G-1

The new G-1 phone based on Google's Android platform is slowing getting out to market this week through T-Mobile stores in U.S. locations where T-Mobile supports the 3G wireless protocol. At launch there appear to be about 50 third party applications available for download to the G-1 via Android Market.
One of those applications is iSkoot for Skype. From iSkoot's description at Android Market:

iSkoot for Skype puts the features of Skype in your Android handset. Acess your Skype contacts, make & receive Skype calls, chat, and place SkypeOut calls to phone numbers all over the world. iSkoot delivers unsurpassed mobile Skype call quality and does not require a WiFi connection.
From the iSkoot press release:
iSkoot for Skype makes it easy and affordable for people to keep in touch with friends, family and contacts with an always-on-the-go lifestyle. iSkoot for Skype leverages the voice-optimized circuit-switched wireless networks of mobile carriers, allowing for full operation even without access to WiFi or 3G networks and ensuring the best possible call quality. Normal carrier voice and data charges always apply.
Make SkypeOut calls? Seems like T-Mobile is the first North America carrier to tolerate SkypeOut calling from a mobile handset over a 3G network. (3 recently added SkypeOut calling to the various Skype/iSkoot-enabled services they support, including Skypephone; Truphone for iPhone only works over a WiFi connection.) T-Mobile will make their revenue through the "local" minutes required to place a Skype call via iSkoot.
VoIP over 3G? Not really, recall that the iSkoot model is to use the data channel for chat messaging and call setup information. The voice call itself is handled over the much more robust and voice-friendly GSM voice channel.
And why iSkoot on the Android platform before on the iPhone? Seems that the Android platform fully supports the background multi-tasking requirement of any Skype-enabled product where you want to have Skype chat sessions running in background - while using any other Android application - and only want to bring them forward when a new message appears. That's my experience when using iSkoot on my Blackberry Bold.
Tags: , , , , ,
Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Blackberry Bold: Challenged to Deliver on Its Full Potential

Over the past five weeks I have had the opportunity to work with the Blackberry Bold on the Rogers network, including a week in California where I used it on AT&T's network. While it has provided significant performance improvements over my previous 8820 and has several applications that just are not available for the iPhone, I still had the feeling I was running with late beta stage or release candidate firmware. The availability of a new firmware release over the past weekend has changed that feeling. But its U.S. release on AT&T has also been dogged by 3G network robustness issues.
Let me put some of these issues in perspective, incorporating my own experience with the Bold on both networks.
There are two major technical issues related to the Bold:

  • Network robustness issues at AT&T
  • Firmware issues that have possibly resulted in suspension of deliveries at Orange (and reports of inventory shortages at other carriers)
First, to cover the AT&T network robustness issues:
  • as reported in RIM's second-quarter report, 60 carriers in 29 countries have launched the Bold, including Canada where I've had a Bold running on Rogers for the past five weeks.
  • several recent news reports have reported on network robustness issues as a contributor to the delayed launch on AT&T: Globe and Mail, TMCNet, CrunchGear
  • a personal indicator: on a recent trip to California both my Blackberry Bold and iPhone 3G found an "EDGE" signal on AT&T more often than it found a 3G signal (in spite of setting the Bold to only operate on 3G). On the Rogers network I find the "3G" signal (in supported urban areas, such as Toronto and Montreal) more than 95 percent of the time.
I have to conclude, combining these issues, that the AT&T network robustness issues are real and serve as a threat to RIM's ability to penetrate the U.S. market via the Bold. On the other hand the pending launch of Blackberry Storm at Verizon may become RIM's primary route to to the U.S. market for their 3G smartphones, given Verizon's reputation for, and experience with, 3G networks along with their extensive customer base. (Why else would several of my U.S.-based blogging colleagues attending the recent IT Expo all be running their laptops on Verizon for Internet connectivity with no complaints?)
Five weeks' experience with the Bold tells me about its firmware:

  • It delivers a significant performance improvement relative to the Blackberry 8820 I have been using for the past year. An half-VGA display with over 200 dpi resolution, 3G network speed and 624 Mhz processor speed all contribute.
  • At no time has my experience to date inhibited my ability to carry on my normal mobile-supported business activities. I have had an opportunity to successfully take advantage of new applications such as editing Word documents.
  • The display grows on you; when you find crystal clear small fonts or view Google Maps, you get this "how did they do this?" feeling. As indicated in other reviews, it's stunning. And the supported resolution is a major contributor to my next point.
  • The Bold is definitely a game changer. After my week of traveling to California with the Bold, I realized that I was experiencing a significant change in my mobile device work patterns. I was simply going to the Bold to keep current not only on email (using a strategic combination of both Blackberry Mail and GMail) but also on my Twitter feed, Facebook and Google Reader. I was able to not only read but also edit Word documents. I had lost the anxiety-inflamed urge to fire up my laptop PC to remain "always connected"; One non-technical acquaintance who has had a Bold since the Rogers launch in late August commented to me last weekend "I'm beginning to think my Bold is more powerful than my notebook".
  • At Mobilize 08 I met Google Maps senior product manager Steve Lee who pointed me to a new version of Google Maps for Blackberry which added Street View to the feature set available on Blackberry. While Google Maps itself is an excellent demonstration of both the Bold's display quality and speed, turning on Street View and either moving down a street or rotating around a selected address brings into play both network and processor speeds to dynamically generate high quality images. (While this is a feature that will be included on Android, it is still not available on the iPhone.)
  • Using Blackberry's MediaSync, I can keep my music files updated by syncing with iTunes. But I also found having the trackball mouse a significant benefit when transcribing our interview with Josh Silverman via the media player; basically I was using the Bold as a Dictaphone.
  • Skype chats running in iSkoot can run in background and provide notification when new chat messages appear. Also when my home office broadband was down recently for a neighborhood cable upgrade, I was able to use iSkoot to call into the daily SquawkBox conference call.
  • Performance on WiFi has been excellent; walk into a registered WiFi zone and the Bold picks it up immediately. The actual registration process itself for a WiFi zone could be smoother but otherwise it works as expected.
  • However, the Bold has been by no means perfect. Web pages would sometimes come up slowly; on some sites I would randomly get either the actual PC version of a page or the mobile version of the site. Sites were often stripped down to their basic content, absent of banners and sidebars. YouTube videos would stall with a "buffering" indicator appearing in the display; I was never able to view the complete video. I started to feel this was late beta stage firmware, not quite ready for "Main Street". And then Friday reports appeared that Orange was possibly suspending Blackberry shipments due to software quality issues.
Friday evening I learned that RIM had released new firmware for Blackberry Bold on Rogers. It was described as addressing browser issues, delivering more stability and improving memory management, amongst other issues. I installed it quite seamlessly Saturday morning with the following immediate observations:
  • The browser is much faster at bringing up standard web pages and renders original web pages correctly. Pages with few "feature enhancements" involving "scripts" load as rapidly as on the iPhone; pages with lots of "scripts" do take longer but are correctly and much more rapidly rendered.
  • YouTube videos can now be played to the end. On some videos I encounter a momentary "buffering" delay but they always went to completion. The actual player itself could provide better video quality to achieve the superb quality I have seen on the Bold's display when mpeg movie files are run but a user can readily follow the YouTube video action.
  • After two days' use, using the phone itself only minimally but with lots of web activity over WiFi, my battery is only down to the 40% level whereas with the earlier version I found I had to always do a daily overnight recharge.
Other issues need a few days' use to determine if they have been addressed. But overall this upgraded Bold firmware appears to spell good news for not only Blackberry Bold but also the Blackberry Storm whose major differences involve radio bands supported, slightly larger display resolution and the type of keyboard but otherwise are based on the same underlying operating system, application and browser firmware.
The question that remains here is whether AT&T can fix their network problems in the near future or will the pending launch of Blackberry Storm become the real Blackberry 3G device launch product? For once I am quite happy to be a Rogers customer where they have spent over a year working with 3G technology prior to the Bold's launch and the network performance is "just there".
Bottom line: the Bold allows new user work patterns for mobile smartphones. It significantly reduces or removes the reliance on laptops to keep current with many communications activities, whether Skype Chat, Twitter Feeds or even minor document modification. Its 480 x 320 display makes it easy to read blog posts without ribbon bars. Background processing allows true multi-tasking. If you're in a country where it is available it is worth checking out (especially once any residual firmware issues are resolved; if you're in the U.S., it's worth having the patience to await its release on AT&T or even the Storm's release on Verizon.
Disclosure: the author has held a minuscule number of RIM shares since 1998.

Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, October 9, 2008

Skype to FCC: Mobile carriers blocking Skype is proof of closed networks

Skype asked the FCC to support unfettered customer freedom following statements at CTIA's conference last month. CTIA and Sprint retorted with balderdash and Skype's Christopher Libertelli sets them straight in this short, direct letter. Emphasis mine. 

    October 8, 2008

    Electronic Filing

    Chairman Kevin J. Martin
    Federal Communications Commission
    445 12th Street, SW
    12th Street Lobby, TW-A325
    Washington, D.C. 20554

    Re: Ex Parte Presentation; RM-11361

    Dear Chairman Martin:

    Skype Communications S.A.R.L. (“Skype”) responds briefly to CTIA’s letter of September 24th and Sprint Nextel’s letter of September 26th, both of which take issue with Skype’s earlier letter to you regarding the lack of openness of wireless networks. CTIA and Sprint go to great lengths to rebut Skype’s characterization of remarks made at a CTIA conference earlier this month, which Skype viewed as indicative of a hesitant, closed network mentality among wireless operators.

    Rather than prolong an empty debate about whose characterization of remarks at the conference is correct, let me point out that Skype’s application is forbidden, blocked and otherwise interfered with by the largest CTIA members.[1] When CTIA members claim that “the entire Internet is open,” the intended implication is that the entire Internet is open, including to multi-modal Internet communications applications like Skype. The truth of the matter, however, is that, despite their representations to the contrary, applications are blocked even on the most recently-announced advanced handsets.[2] The proof of Skype’s argument is in the conduct of CTIA members, no matter what speeches are made at conferences. If Skype is blocked, the network is not open.

    I also would like to take this opportunity to remind you that CTIA is currently suing the Commission to overturn the very openness rule they now claim to embrace. If the wireless industry is serious about openness, CTIA would immediately withdraw that litigation.

    CTIA attempts to sidestep the fact that its members’ networks are not open by arguing that Skype itself is closed and, apparently, therefore cannot advocate consumer empowerment principles and network openness. To make this point, they cite a blog post by Mr. Michael Robertson, CEO of Gizmo Project, a VOIP application. Fundamentally, Mr. Robertson is wrong. Mr. Robertson confuses open networks with open platforms. Skype is an open platform. Anyone, anywhere on the planet can download Skype for free, and he or she will be able to use Skype. Skype’s software is open to any application developer through our public Application Programming Interface (‘API’) program. Over 10,000 developers have taken advantage of this API and are part of Skype’s developer program. In fact there are many applications that use Skype’s APIs to send calls to/from Skype users and SIP endpoints, including VoSky, Fring, etc. Skype also recently collaborated with Digium/Asterisk, which will now bring Skype into “soft PBXs” for millions of users and allow many forms of applications and services to connect to Skype seamlessly.

    Mr. Robertson is also wrong on the law. He rehashes the incumbent wireless operators’ various arguments against network neutrality and confuses to whom the Internet Policy Statement applies. Openness rules are properly targeted at network operators because of the limited intermodal choices available to US consumers in a wireless market dominated by the top three operators. Conversely, there is nearly limitless choice in Internet applications, with fierce competition and few or no barriers to entry. Quite properly, therefore, the Internet Policy Statement applies to networks and not to applications. Its aim is to assure an open Internet so that consumers can choose from the limitless number of applications available to Internet users, absent discrimination by network operators. To apply it to Internet applications would flipt the Internet Policy statement on its head. What the network operators are doing is very different. They restrict consumer choice by blocking Skype and other applications to which consumers would like to have access. To apply the Internet Policy Statement to Internet applications would flip the Policy Statement on its head.

    We greatly appreciate CTIA’s invitation to attend the April show in Las Vegas. If CTIA members would like to prove their openness once and for all, Skype’s top executives will be available to attend the conference. When a Skype user can legally call the Chairman of the FCC on the mobile broadband networks of each of the top three wireless networks, we will know that their conduct is consistent with the consumer empowerment principles of the Internet Policy Statement.

    We look forward to working with the Commission and CTIA members to ensure that the whole Internet – including multimodal applications such as Skype – is available to consumers.

    Respectfully submitted,

    Christopher Libertelli
    Senior Director, Government and Regulatory Affairs
    SKYPE COMMUNICATIONS S.A.R.L.
    6e etage, 22/24 boulevard Royal,
    Luxembourg, L-2449 LUXEMBOURG

     

    1. Most network operators continue to restrict VoIP and or P2P applications on their network in apparent violation of the protocol-agnostic network management techniques employed by other operators, including Comcast.

    2. See, e.g., Daniel Roth, Android: No VOIP for You -- and Other Oddities With the Google Phone. Sep. 23, 2008. In addition, commenting on the iPhone’s closed operating system, Steve Wozniak, co-founder of Apple Computer, said "Consumers aren't getting all they want when companies are very proprietary and lock their products down...I would like to write some more powerful apps than what you're allowed." Oct 8, 2008

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

My "Back to the Future" Experience

When I started learning about the new Google Chrome browser yesterday, ghosts of past PC software were awakened. In a post on GigaOm, Chrome-Induced Deja Vu, I have related how reading about Google Chrome as a web browser brought back thoughts of my days involving Quarterdeck where we had a product that provided application multi-tasking and dealt with memory management issues on DOS-based PC's as early as twenty-two years ago. The post concludes with a summary of my thoughts on where Google Chrome will play a role in the ongoing evolution of Web 2.0.

One final question: Can we ever expect to see Skype have any advantages as a web-based application?

Powered by Qumana

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Blackberry: The Smartphone for Wilderness Survival

Several years ago, while skiing at Whistler, a member of our party broke her leg in the most remote (but still in-bounds) glacier (Blackcomb Glacier) with only one route in and out. Having cell phone access resulted in having the ski patrol on the scene within about five minutes and timely removal from the mountain to the hospital. It was critical that the cell phone rf sensitivity in this somewhat remote location was sufficient to make a call.
The past couple of weekends has found me in Ontario's summer cottage areas north of Toronto where distance, remoteness and low population density can provide significant challenges to a mobile phone's usefulness and service availability in emergencies. With no landline Internet connections available I left my laptop at home and tested the bounds of what I could follow simply using mobile devices. Amongst the issues I encountered were:
  • Battery: how long is battery life and how easily can you replace a battery?
  • Rf sensitivity: can I make a phone call with weak connectivity (<1 bar)?
  • Real time navigation: can I follow my progress in a boat as the boat moves along?
In my case I was traveling with both a Blackberry 8820 and iPhone 3G, each connected to the Rogers GSM 3G/EDGE network. The 8820 could only use EDGE for data but the voice channel was the same for both. My experiences:
  • Battery Life: the Blackberry was the clear winner requiring much less frequent charging (if at all) in a 2- to 3-day trip. But Blackberry is reknown for its battery management features; if desired as backup, you can take along charged replacement batteries.
  • Rf sensitivity: this one really surprised me but also says a lot about the iPhone 3G connection problems being reported. I was at a location on a small lake 6 km by air southwest of Gravenhurst, Ontario (location of the nearest tower) with less that one bar of reception and attempted to make phone calls. The iPhone came up with a screen announcing that it could not make a voice call while, sitting in the same seat, the Blackberry had no problems making a voice call - all over the same Rogers network via the same Rogers cell tower. Amongst the group I was visiting two other Verizon-enabled Blackberries could make calls through the local equidistant Telus cell tower while another person with an iPhone also could not make calls through the Rogers tower. As further affirmation of the Blackberry's superior rf sensitivity, when I drove into this location, the Blackberry was receiving updated Google Maps data (over EDGE) right up until I reached my destination.
  • Real time marine navigation: We also experienced some boat trips on Muskoka Lake, which is laden with many islands, bays and inlets, both large and small. On this popular lake with many cottagers there is good-to-excellent Rogers 3G coverage. Let's just say that on our first trip the boat's driver did not know the exact location of a marina we were seeking out. What I found was that while the satellite view of Google Maps on the Blackberry could provide very helpful location and direction information in real time, Google Maps on the iPhone could only provide occasional "static" information but not effectively track one's progress. On the other hand it has been known that iPhone is not capable of the real time navigation critical to the resolution of our situation. Asking a local cottager got us headed in the right direction towards the location of the marina but having real time navigation in Google Maps made it a significantly easier to reach our destination. As would be expected Google Maps does not provide complete marine navigation information such as depth isobars, underwater rock locations, etc. but, knowing the main channels, it became a critical support tool as we found our way.
My conclusions:

  • The 3G connectivity issues being reported for the iPhone probably involve both the rf sensitivity issue I experienced as well as carrier issues. By maintaining internal design control of the Blackberry's rf circuitry, RIM has brought into play 11 years of experience in developing wireless products. Contrary to other reports that attempt to lay the blame for iPhone 3G connectivity problems solely on the networks, the iPhone's device engineering, reportedly using a third party 3G chip, is a contributing issue to the problem. (During my time as a research physicist involving the design of rf detection circuitry, the rf sensitivity issue was a critical factor in detecting 13C signals using magnetic resonance spectroscopy for determining the molecular structure of drugs and other chemical formulations.)
  • Real time navigation is just not viable on the iPhone. Pretty Google Maps but if they cannot track your progress in real time, not a big help. Especially when you're lost on a lake with as many islands and inlets as Muskoka Lake. iPhone's GPS can find me the nearest five Tim Hortons locations but combine my boating experience with the repeatedly reported inability of the iPhone to multi-task effectively and you have to come to the conclusion the iPhone is simply lacking in processing speed to perform true on-the-go navigation.
  • And on long trips, away from a source for recharging, take along a couple of spare batteries.
Before every iPhone defender jumps on the bandwagon, I appreciate many of the iPhone's features. It's a great device for personal voice communications and and one way information delivery such as browsing activity and even receiving email (via GMail). But, it's not up to the capabilities and standards of the Blackberry line when it comes to needing robust communications and processing horsepower.
Bottom line: everybody worries about 911 access for providing emergency communications. But when you travel into more remote, weakly serviced areas you want the most robust mobile device for maintaining reliably effective voice and data communications when emergencies arise. In this case I want a Blackberry, thank you.
(Note: Nokia N95 testing is yet to occur due to limitations on the number of SIM's immediately available.)
Tags: , , , , , ,
Powered by Qumana

Labels: , , , , , , , ,